Today's Baltimore City is a Cold War-era KGB agent's wet dream. There's cameras everywhere. More accurately, if Baltimore Police Lt. Samuel Hood's vision is realized, there will be.
I learned this during the 1st Annual Baltimore Tech Crawl, whose second stop was the Baltimore Police’s Citiwatch control center. Here, Lt. Hood gave a presentation (to me and my fellow crawlers), during which he noted that the system currently has 609 cameras in place. However, not-too-distant plans call for thousands of cameras.
Lt. Hood ended the presentation with a selection of recorded footage showing crimes in process, frequently with officers arriving onto the scene within seconds. It was all very impressive - what with all those cameras manned continuously by (for the most part) retired police officers.
Being that (almost) everyone on the crawl was a techie, and that techies tend to be a forward-looking lot, many quietly expressed reservations about the program - and its expansion.
In one sense, it's very comforting - knowing that somebody's keeping an eye out for you. In another sense, it's very frightening - knowing that you're always being watched.
However, I didn't sense even a smidgen of trepidation in Lt. Hood's presentation of the program. He talked of the program's success like a proud poppa. He was almost giddy when talking of the expanding camera count and the prospects of tapping into private camera networks.
It's this unapologetically see-no-warts attitude, completely devoid of any counter-balancing voice that bothered me the most. I would have liked to have heard at least some mention of restraint or drawbacks, but I didn't catch any.
"No more anonymity, not in Baltimore, not downtown."
- Baltimore Police Lt. Samuel Hood
Public and Beyond
The fact of the matter is that these cameras are recording activity in public spaces. There shouldn't be any expectation of privacy there. I get that. Even the private camera networks are typically trained on public (albeit sometimes enclosed) spaces.
The inevitable question is, of course, where does it stop? The natural answer is "at home". But technology is tricky. What are the implications for the part of our lives spent online? On the internet, what's the equivalent of a public space? Is it all private? All public?